By now, you are probably aware that the “Safeguard Mechanism” will commence on 1 July 2016.  However, what probably remains less certain is whether your company is covered by the Safeguard Mechanism and, if it is, what you have to do over the coming months. This legal update aims to simplify the steps you need to undertake, and the timing of those steps, in order to ensure your company complies with the Safeguard Mechanism in 2016/17.

This legal update has been developed in conjunction with Norton Rose Fulbright’s experienced Sustainability and Climate Change team, who support their clients by providing solid advice on the choices and decisions necessary for responding to a risk, opportunity or both.

This update is not exhaustive regarding all Safeguard Mechanism requirements. Instead we have covered some of the time critical points and some key concessions businesses will need to consider to mitigate compliance costs from exceeding their baseline into the future.

 

What you Need to Know and do Now

Right now you need to consider whether your company is likely to be covered by the Safeguard Mechanism, which is the liable company (responsible emitter) and whether a baseline number defined by historic reported NGER data is appropriate for your facility.

 

 Is Your Facility Covered?

The Safeguard Mechanism will apply to companies operating one or more facilities which emit more than 100,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2-e) “covered emissions” in a financial year. Covered emissions are all direct (scope 1) emissions covered by the National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting (Methodology Determination) 2008 (subject to exceptions for landfills and electricity generators).

For companies already covered by the National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting Scheme (NGERs), you should review your NGERs reports submitted since 2009/10 to determine whether any one facility has reported scope 1 emissions of 100,000 t CO2-e or more in any financial year. It is not necessary to count the scope 2 emissions (i.e. from grid electricity or steam consumption) included in your report. This review will be a good indicator of whether your facility is likely to exceed the threshold in 2016/17. Additionally, it will be necessary to consider whether your facility will be subject to any expansion or increase in production which may cause the facility to meet the threshold in the future.

 If you are not already reporting under NGERs, you are unlikely to be covered by the Safeguard Mechanism, unless your facility has undergone a recent expansion, or you have a new investment or you are a non-constitutional corporation (such as a local council) which operates a large facility. In these scenarios, you should review your facility’s projected emissions to check if the threshold will be exceeded in the future.

 

Who is the Liable Company?

 Once you have determined that your facility emits more than 100,000 t CO2-e, it is necessary to determine which company has “operational control” of the facility and will therefore be responsible for compliance under the Safeguard Mechanism. This will be the company with authority to introduce and implement any or all of the operating policies; health and safety policies and environmental policies. Where there are multiple companies operating at one facility, it is usually necessary to review the contractual arrangements in place at the facility to determine which company has operational control.

 It is important to be aware that the company liable under the Safeguard Mechanism will not necessarily be the same company which is currently reporting under NGERs (as the reporting company under NGERs is usually the “highest controlling corporation”, whereas the liable company under the Safeguard Mechanism will be the one actually operating the facility).

 

Is a ‘Reported’ Baseline Appropriate?

The default position for companies reporting under NGERs is that your facility will be given a ‘reported’ baseline, based on NGERs data for the five year period between 2009/10 and 2013/14 (see below).

 However, there are certain concessions included in the Safeguard Mechanism for facilities that expect to exceed their reported baseline, notably an ‘initial calculated baseline’ (covered further below in a practical case-study). The initial calculated baseline should be considered as your ‘cover-all free kick’ if you think you may exceed your reported baseline in 2016/17, being the ‘initial’ year of the Safeguard Mechanism.

 To take advantage of a calculated baseline, right now, you need to understand what your baseline for 2016/17 will be. You can calculate this yourself based on the forecast production and emissions intensity for your facility. This will be your default emissions target. In order to manage your exposure, you should know this target well before 31 July 2016 (the first application deadline), because if you overshoot your baseline, you may need to purchase Australian Carbon Credit Units (ACCUs) for every tonne of emissions ‘overshot’.

 

Before 31 July 2016

 

Reported Baseline Calculation

The reported baseline for large facilities will be calculated by the Clean Energy Regulator (Regulator) and as mentioned will be based on your reported NGERs data for the five year period between 2009/10 and 2013/14.  The Regulator will initiate the reported baseline setting process by advising responsible emitters of their proposed facility baseline number. The Regulator aims to contact all responsible emitters with their proposed reported baselines by May 2016.

 If you satisfy the reported baseline criteria and believe that your projected emissions into the foreseeable future will remain below your highest reported scope 1 emissions value from 2009/10 to 2013/2014, then no further action regarding baselines is likely to be required. You should not  trigger the historic baseline and will not be required to purchase ACCUs.

 

Optional Reported Baseline for Some Facilities

 Facilities that only reported scope 1 emissions under NGERs in some of the 5 years from 2009/10-2013/14 may have a choice to opt-in to receive a reported baseline number. If you have reported scope 1 emissions under NGERs four or less times in the five years from 2009 and have only reached the threshold of more than 100,000 tonnes covered emissions in one to three of those years, you can either:

  1. Request a reported baseline determination, which requires you to notify the Regulator by 31 July 2016; or
  2. Use the calculated baseline approach under the new facility criteria, which requires you to submit an application by 31 October 2017 along with an independent audit report.

If you are in this position and don’t follow options 1 or 2 above, the Regulator will give you a default baseline number of 100,000.

For a reported baseline determination, the Regulator will provide you with feedback regarding the proposed baseline and provide opportunity for comment / consultation before the actual determination is made. Once a reported baseline determination is issued for your facility, it will no longer meet the new facility criteria for a calculated baseline.

 

Calculated Baselines

 If you expect your facility’s baseline emissions to exceed your reported baseline, then it is recommended that you consider applying for a ‘new’ baseline under the calculated baseline criteria. This is your ‘free-kick’!

 For a calculated baseline that begins from 1 July 2016, applications can be submitted between 1 July 2016 and 31 October 2017. The baseline is determined by the highest expected production level of a primary production variable (and corresponding emissions) over the three-year period covered by the calculated baseline determination (2016/17 to 2018/19 for a baseline determination starting 1 July 2016).  However, the years of production you can choose from to set your baseline are limited by the date from which you apply:

  • to use the highest production level from all three years to determine your baseline, you need to submit your application by 30 July 2016; otherwise
  • if you submit your application by 30 July 2017, you can use the highest of the last two years (2017/18; 2018/19) to determine your baseline number; alternately
  • if you submit your application after 30 July 2017 and by 31 October 2017, your emissions baseline number will be established from your projected production level in 2018/19 only.

Because these application dates are not straight forward, we have provided a practical case study further below to illustrate when applications need to be submitted. You can also see Ndevr Environmental’s recent article on key dates for calculated baseline applications here. It is important to understand forecast emissions early to make an informed decision about when to submit your application, accompanied by an audit report.

The calculated baseline provides an opportunity for facilities to ‘adjust upwards’ their baseline, if it is reasonably expected that the facility’s emissions will increase. The specified criteria to be eligible for the calculated baseline include:

  • increase or expected increase of baseline emissions within the first year 2016-17 of the Safeguard Mechanism (initial baseline criteria)
  • new facilities that forecast expected emissions of 100 000 t CO2-e in the first year of the calculated baseline (new facility criteria)
  • facilities in the natural resource sector that have variable emissions due to resource extraction or the quality of the grade ore (inherent emissions variability criteria)
  • when facilities expect their baseline to be permanently increased if there is a production capacity growth greater than 20% (significant expansion criteria).

If you think your facility will satisfy one or more of the calculated baseline criteria, then you can apply to the Regulator for a calculated baseline. Generally, the calculated baseline is determined by the following calculation:

 

Calculated baseline = forecast production x forecast emissions intensity

 

Because the initial calculated baseline option is likely to be of interest to industry, and important dates are approaching, we have prepared an abridged case-study to demonstrate how a company might apply for an ‘initial calculated baseline’.

 

Case Study

 You have operational control of Facility ‘X’. Based on the past emissions for Facility ‘X’ in Figure 1 below, the reported baseline will be 300,000 t CO2-e.

 

Figure 1. Past emissions Profile

 Based on your projected future emissions in Table 1 below, you think you will exceed this (reported) baseline as soon as the Safeguard Mechanism starts.

Table 1. Future Emissions and Production Profile

Variable

2016/17

2017/18

2018/19

Forecast Units of Production (Million Units)

450

300

350

Forecast Emissions Intensity per Unit

1kg CO2-e per unit

1kg CO2-e per unit

1kg CO2-e per unit

Covered Emissions

450,000 tCO2-e

300,000 tCO2-e

350,000 tCO2-e

 

What can you do?

 In this scenario, if the facility was to rely on a historic ‘reported’ baseline (300,000 tCO2-e from the 2012/13 year) it would be subject to the costs demonstrated in Table 2.

Table 2. Outcome of Relying on a Reported Baseline

Variable

2016/17

2017/18

2018/19

Baseline 

300,000 tCO2-e

Covered Emissions

450,000 tCO2-e

300,000 tCO2-e

350,000 tCO2-e

‘Excess Emissions’ (ACCUs for purchase)

150,000 tCO2-e (150,000 ACCUs)

0

50,000 tCO2-e

(50,000 ACCUs)

Safeguard Mechanism cost to business (ACCUs @$12.25 * each)

$1,837,500

0

$612,500

*Weighted average price for ACCUs at ERF Auction 2, November 2015

 

For Facility ‘X’, assuming it can source ACCUs at $12.25 each over the next three years (equal to the weighted average price paid by the Government at ERF Auction 2), the direct cost to business over the three years is $2,450,000.

In this instance Facility ‘X’ should look to apply for an initial calculated baseline.

Under Figure 2, Facility ‘X’ should establish its baseline number using production levels in 2016/17, which will present the highest production level and therefore covered emissions during the three year calculated baseline determination period.

Figure 2. Past emissions, projected emissions and application dates for calculated baseline determination beginning 1 July 2016

 

Using the forecast production and emissions intensity from Table 1, the calculated baseline would be as follows:

Calculated baseline                    = forecast production x forecast emissions intensity

                                                = 450M units x 1kg CO2-e per unit

                                                = 450,000 tCO2-e

With an initial calculated baseline in place, Facility ‘X’ would have no cost to business, other than compliance costs associated with auditing and developing the initial calculated baseline demonstrated in Table 3.

 

Table 3. Outcome of Relying on an Initial Calculated Baseline

Variable

2016/17

2017/18

2018/19

Baseline 

450,000 tCO2-e

Covered Emissions

450,000 tCO2-e

300,000 tCO2-e

350,000 tCO2-e

‘Excess Emissions’ (ACCUs for purchase)**

-

(0 ACCUs)

(150,000 tCO2-e)

(0 ACCUs)

(50,000 tCO2-e)

(0 ACCUs)

Safeguard Mechanism cost to business (ACCUs @$12.25 * each)

-

-

-

**Excess emissions compared to reported baseline. Note the facility cannot generate ACCUs by emitting less than its initial calculated baseline.

In this simplified case study, Facility ‘X’ is in a much better position by utilising an initial calculated baseline. Excluding the costs of auditing and developing the initial calculated baseline, the facility is $2,450,000 in front.

Importantly, as per Figure 2, because Facility ‘X’ wants to establish its baseline number on forecast emissions from the 2016/17 year, which will present the highest covered emissions during the three year calculated baseline determination period, it must submit its application and audit report by 30 July 2016.

If the application is submitted after 30 July 2016 and by 30 July 2017, then the baseline number for the three year period will be based on only the last two years of forecast emissions, which in this case  is 350,000 tCO2-e (in 2018/19). For Facility ‘X’, because projected emissions in year 3 of the baseline determination period are higher than in year 2, the baseline number will be the same if the application is submitted after 30 July 2017 but before and by the final deadline of 31 October 2017 (and therefore based on the final year only).

Here, even after taking advantage of a three multi-year monitoring period which allows Facility ‘X’ to take the average emissions across the three years (366,666 tCO2-e), Facility ‘X’ will still need to offset 50,000 t CO2-e to avoid an excess emissions situation at the end of the monitoring period. As noted below, applications for multi-year monitoring period beginning 2016/17 are also due by 31 October 2017.

To avoid significant costs in this scenario, it is highly beneficial for Facility ‘X’s responsible emitter to submit its initial baseline application and accompanying audit by 30 July 2016.

 

After 1 July 2017

 Following the end of the compliance year, you will be required to report as usual under NGERs, by 31 October 2017.

If it becomes apparent that your facility exceeded its baseline in 2016/17, there are various flexible mechanisms you can use to manage compliance as follows:

  • apply to the Regulator for a variation of a baseline determination if your facility has had expanding production accompanied by an emissions intensity improvement, by 31 October 2017;
  • apply to the Regulator for an exemption declaration because the excess emissions situation was caused by criminal activity or natural disturbance, by 31 October 2017; or
  • apply to the Regulator to report as part of a multi-year period, by 31 October 2017.

 Finally, if it becomes apparent that your facility has exceeded its baseline and you have not been able to take advantage of the above flexible mechanisms, you may surrender ACCUs to cover your emissions excess by 28 February 2018.

 From 1 March 2018, if your facility exceeded its baseline in 2016/17 and you have not surrendered ACCUs to offset that exceedance, the Regulator may seek to impose a civil penalty on you. The maximum penalty is the lesser of 100 penalty points per day (currently $18,000 per day), with a maximum of 10,000 penalty points ($1.8 million).

 

Moving Forward

 While this update has focused on Safeguard Mechanism compliance in the immediate future, important differences will apply to new facilities post 2020, which will have their baseline set using emissions intensity industry benchmarks. The Department of Environment has recently issued draft guidelines on how these emissions intensity benchmarks will be established. The draft guidelines are open for public consultation with submissions due by 5.00 pm AEST on 6 May 2016.

This update sets some of the key upcoming dates and requirements to comply with the Safeguard Mechanism over the next couple of years. This update is not exhaustive; businesses have other options to manage liability under the Safeguard Mechanism and there are many complexities that we will cover in future updates.

 

For further queries call Ndevr Environmental Director Matt Drum:

http://www.ndevrenvironmentalconsulting.com.au/contact-us

Published in Blog

Considering adjusting your emissions baseline under the safeguard mechanism to cover increased emissions and avoid unnecessary offset costs? This article highlights key dates for applications and audit reports under the safeguard mechanism for facilities applying the calculated baseline approach to determine their baseline emissions number. For detailed information about the safeguard mechanism, including who is covered and how baseline emissions numbers are measured, see our recent blog: Safeguard Mechanism - What you need to know

Background

The safeguard mechanism begins 1 July 2016, and provides several approaches for measuring the emissions baseline number for large facilities (with emissions greater than 100,000 tonnes carbon dioxide equivalent), against which the facility's greenhouse gas emissions performance will be monitored.

Generally, if your facility has reported NGER scope 1 emissions greater than 100,000 tonnes carbon dioxide equivalent, the Clean Energy Regulator will issue a reported baseline emissions determination, based on historic NGER data, for that facility. If you are satisfied that this reported baseline determination is appropriate, you do not need to submit an application or audit report under the safeguard mechanism. However, there are a number of circumstances where historic emissions will be inappropriate, and you may prefer to apply a calculated emissions baseline approach to measure your facility’s baseline. Circumstances in which which calculated baselines are available include if your facility (i) is new, (ii) has undergone a significant expansion, (iii) has inherent emissions variability (applicable to natural resource sector), or (iv) is likely to exceed the reported (historic) baseline number in 2016/17 financial year (for further details, see Safeguard Mechanism - What you need to know).

If you require a calculated emissions baseline determination, you will need to submit an application and accompanying audit report to the Clean Energy Regulator.

Application and audit due dates for Calculated Emissions Baseline Determinations

The time at which you should submit your application and audit report for a calculated-emissions baseline determination depends on your circumstances. For calculated baselines that are to commence in the 2016-17 financial year, the ultimate deadline for applications, with accompanying audit reports, isn’t until 31 October 2017. (See Safeguard Rule subsection 22(3)). However, you may need to submit your application earlier, because the years that you can choose from to establish your baseline are limited by the timing of your application.

The general rule under the calculated baseline approach is that the year chosen to establish the baseline is in the future from when the application is made. This means that the quantity of emissions intensity must be estimated, rather than based on historic data. The rule aims to reduce the risk that emissions and emissions intensity are deliberately increased in a year in order to artificially increase the baseline.

The table below highlights which years can be considered in establishing the facility baseline emissions number for a determination beginning 1 July 2016, depending on the application timing.

Date Application Submitted

Baseline Year

Application (and accompanying audit) received by the Regulator before 31 July 2016

Financial year with the highest expected production of the primary production variable over the three year period to be covered by the determination (2016/17-2018/19) (or five years if it is a large new facility). [subparagraph 27(1)(c)(i)]

Application (and accompanying audit) received by the Regulator between 31 July 3016 - 30 July 2017

Financial year with the highest expected production of the primary production variable of the last two years to be covered by the determination (2017/18 – 2018/19) (or last four years if it is a large new facility). [subparagraph 27(1)(c)(ii)]

Application (and accompanying audit) received after 31 July 2017 and by deadline 31 October 2017.

The last financial year of the three year period to be covered by the determination (2018/19) (or last three years if it is a large new facility). [subparagraph 27(1)(c)(iii)]

 

Application timing for Initial Baseline Determinations

While timing of applications is a relevant consideration for all calculated baseline determinations, it will be particularly relevant for initial baseline determinations, which must commence in the first year of the safeguard mechanism, i.e. 1 July 2016. The initial baseline criteria allows for baselines to be adjusted if facilities expect to exceed their baseline in the safeguard mechanism’s first year. The baseline will be increased to reflect forecast emissions, using the calculated emissions baseline approach, similarly to the approach for new investments or significant expansion of a facility covered by the safeguard mechanism before 2020.

Applying the rules regarding application timing set out above, if your company expects to exceed its historic baseline in 2016/17, and otherwise meets the initial baseline emissions criteria, you may consider applying for an initial baseline determination, which will normally apply for a three year period from 1 July 2016 – 30 June 2019.

The following requirements must be met for an initial calculated baseline (noting that Grid connected electricity generators are not eligible to utilise the initial calculated baseline criteria):

  1. The facility must either have a reported-emissions baseline determination or have submitted emissions reports under the NGER Act for the five years starting on 1 July 2009.
  2. The facility has exceeded or expects to exceed its baseline emissions number in 2016‑17. Note that facilities must not deliberately increase or intend to increase their covered emissions for the purpose of meeting this criterion, e.g. by changing how emissions are reported or calculated or causing scope 1 emissions.

(For further details on these criterion, see the Safeguard Rule, section 26.)

When making your application, you will need to choose the appropriate year in the period covered by the calculated emissions baseline determination from which to set you baseline. Normally, this is the year with the highest (forecast) production level. However, the years from which you can chose are limited by the timing of your application, as noted above. So, If you want forecast emissions for 2016-17 to be included in the financial years from which your baseline can be established, you need to make your application before 31 July 2016 (see subparagraph 27(1)(c)(i) of the Safeguard Rule).

Similarly, if your intention is to use forecast production variable quantities for 2017-18 to calculate the baseline, you will need to submit the application with accompanying audit report before 31 July 2017 (see subparagraph 27(1)(c)(ii) of the Rule). It is important to be aware that baselines may be adjusted at the end of the 3 year calculated baseline determination where actual emissions are significantly different from forecast emissions.

 

Further information

This article provides general information only and is not intended to replace official Government information. Stakeholders should seek their own advice on how the rules, including key dates, apply to their individual circumstances. If you would like more information specific to your company’s circumstances, our dedicated and experienced team can assist you.

Our contact details are at:

http://www.ndevrenvironmentalconsulting.com.au/contact-us

If you would like further general information, or to review the Safeguard legislation and explanatory statement, you can visit:

Published in Blog